One thing I forgot to mention in my season 3 finale post was the connection or lack of connection between Penelope (Desmonds’ Girl), Naomi, the parachute girl and the boat (if there is one).
When Charlie was talking to Penny, she said “what boat?” meaning she was not connected to Naomi’s boat like Naomi has told our losties. This raises so many questions I’m not even sure where to start, but I’ll try:
1. If Penelope doesn’t know about the boat, whose boat is it?
2. Is there really a boat? Or is Naomi lying?
3. If Penny doesn’t know Naomi, how and why does Naomi have a picture of Desmond and Penny with her?
I really am not sure what to think of the connection, but I’d love to hear what you all think about the Penny / Naomi / Boat connection in the comments below