He obviously lied to Jack when he told him he was a champion swimmer. However, when he swam down into the station, that was no easy feat. Shit I proably couldnt have held my breath that long, apparently the whole “can Charlie swim or cant he?” thing really mindfucked the writers.

Theres an episode where at the begining jack helps Boone from drowning bcos he was helping another surviver from drowning. As Jack finds out who is out in the ocean he asks charlie who is in the water and charlie ses the persons name then charlie says “i wud go and help myself but i cant swim” then u fast forward to season3 and he mentions hw hes a gud swimmer and he shud go to underwater hatch

The producers love to have those happy little reunion moments with their characters. Jin and Sun’s will be a big one. Especially with the baby and everything. Maybe Jin will buy her a stuffed panda.

i think season 4 is really weird, even a bit stupid from time to time… i thought it was kind of lame that the island was moved!

I dotn think Jin is dead either, he could have easily outlived the explosion. However, problem is that the island disappeared so where could he have gone… eventually he must have drowned… or PEnny’s boat found him just after the O6 departure… we’ll see!

Here is the link:

http://www.moviehole.net/200816269-lost-season-five-promo-online

Very interesting…. (not sold on it though)…but I do understand how one can rationalize for themselves that theory. Yes Adam i agree…. Locke thing OLD…lol. Scott please oh please start another topic of discussion…

Oh Adam…. I got the Season 3 for $25 last year…lol. Fortunately it was at a used bookstore… Got lucky on that one. I can’t imagine a brand new season whatever edition going for $25… I would like to know where too.

Oh yeah…. I almost forgot EXCELLENT perpective on the HansO name thing….

Well, if there is no history beetween Jack and the Island, what is the part of Jack’s father Christian? To what i believe is that Christian has been on the Island. I sure can’t figure why but he’s been there before! Just think:
Christian was an Alchoolic doctor struggling to maintane his career achievments, he seemed to manage this for a while
but afterwards there he goes again with the drinking part!…
So, how did Jack ended up in his flashforwards?
And if all this proves to be true…
1. What was Christian doing on the Island?
2. Why and how did he left?
3. We know that there is allready a child out of marriage for Christian (that is Clair) so why not another one? (meaning Jack)
4. Ok… there seems to be a problem with childbirths on the island according to Juliet…but whas this always the case? What if this “malfaction” let say is actually the so called incident? And if so, where there any other children born on the island before (for example let’s say Charlotte?)

thanks

Unfortunatelly, I haven’t be able to find a reliable source on that theory, that’s why i seeked here for answers. What i know on this is that this Theory is widely spread in Greece among the Lost Fans! What’s more is that some of the supporters of this “outcome” say that Jacks is actually originated from the island or that there is history between him and the island! Their proof to this is that on the very first episode of season 1 when the plane crashes Jack comes out of the Jungle while the passengers who were seeting near him came out of the sea being wet!

It may be just Fan theories of what lies beneath! Who knows?